Mike LawlerNick LaLotaAndrew GarbarinoNicole MalliotakisNick LangworthyClaudia Tenney Voting Rights New York

New York Election 2026: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

Cait Conley beat Mike Lawler 53% to 47%, and Democrats won back a two-thirds supermajority in the state Senate, including an East End seat Republicans had held since 1914. Nick LaLota and Andrew Garbarino survived by about 2 and 3 points. And Nicole Malliotakis ran on a map a state judge had ordered redrawn, until the U.S. Supreme Court stepped in.

New York Election 2026: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
Photo: Nila Roper / City & State New York

On Election Night, New York voters threw out one of the Republicans on this site, gave the governor her biggest win yet, and handed Democrats back a supermajority in the state Senate.

Five of the six Republicans we track here still won. But every one of them won by less than two years ago, and two of them on Long Island barely held on. The one New York City Republican kept her seat on a map a state judge had already said she couldn't use, because the U.S. Supreme Court said she could.

Here's the good, the bad and the ugly.

The good: Mike Lawler is out

Democrat Cait Conley beat Rep. Mike Lawler in the 17th District, 53.0% to 46.9%, with 98% counted as of Nov. 15. That's a margin of more than 19,000 votes. Two years ago Lawler won the same seat with 52.2%.

Lawler conceded around 11 p.m. on election night, before much of Westchester County had even been counted. "When all of the votes are counted tomorrow in Westchester, it's going to be pretty clear that we will be short," he told supporters in Pearl River.

The race turned in Rockland County. According to City & State, Lawler carried it by 18 points last time. This year he was up only about 8. Conley, an Army combat veteran, tied him to Trump at every chance, and City & State wrote that his breaks with the president couldn't make up for his votes for tariffs and his support for the war in Iran. "This wasn't a partisan fight, this was a patriotic fight," she said.

Lawler's last week was rough. Days before the vote, a federal lawsuit said canvassers brought in from five states to knock doors for him were paid as little as $1 a door. At his final forum he claimed he'd delivered "the largest tax cut in American history", a claim PolitiFact had rated Mostly False when other Republicans made it.

With Lawler gone, Republicans hold 6 of New York's 26 House seats.

The rest of the good news:

  • The state Senate supermajority is back. Going in, Democrats held 41 of the 63 seats, one short of a supermajority, the two-thirds it takes to override a veto. City & State reported they were on track to gain about six seats, and NY1 reported that Democrats "once again have a supermajority" in the Senate. In Rockland, Nyack Mayor Joseph Rand beat Republican Sen. Bill Weber by nearly 10,000 votes in a district Trump won by 11. In southern Brooklyn, Larry He beat Republican Sen. Steve Chan, 57% to 42%. Lisa Kaul unseated Sen. Rob Rolison in the Hudson Valley, and longtime Sen. Jim Tedisco conceded to law professor Sarah Rogerson in Saratoga County.
  • A Long Island seat that had been Republican since 1914. Democrat Chris Murray beat Republican Sen. Anthony Palumbo on the East End, 62,408 to 58,344 with all but one district reporting. Palumbo left Murray a voicemail conceding the next day.
  • Assembly seats in southern Brooklyn. Joey Cohen-Saban beat Republican Assembly Member Michael Novakhov by about 24 points. Chris McCreight beat Assembly Member Alec Brook-Krasny by nearly 11 in a rematch, according to City & State. Upstate, Chloe Pierce beat Assembly Member Scott Bendett on her second try.
  • The governor won big, even on Long Island. Kathy Hochul beat Republican Bruce Blakeman 59.7% to 40.0%, with 95% counted as of Nov. 15. Four years ago she beat Lee Zeldin by just 6 points. Zeldin carried Long Island 57% to 43% in 2022. This time Hochul narrowly won Suffolk, and in Nassau, "the county Blakeman has run since 2022," she took nearly 51%. Democrats also won the Town of Hempstead, beating Republican Supervisor John Ferretti. That's only the second time in a century they've won Town Hall there.
  • Letitia James won by 20. The attorney general beat Republican Saritha Komatireddy 60.1% to 39.8%. In 2022 she won with 54.6%.

The bad: they won, by less

All five Republicans on this site who won Tuesday did worse than in 2024. Counts are NBC's as of Nov. 15.

The ugly: the Supreme Court saved the last Republican in New York City

Nicole Malliotakis is the only Republican in Congress from New York City. Her district covers all of Staten Island and part of southern Brooklyn. She won Tuesday by 12 points. She did it on a map that a New York judge had already thrown out.

What the judge ruled

In October 2025, four Staten Island residents sued, represented by the Elias Law Group, a firm that brings redistricting cases for Democrats. They said the 11th District's lines watered down the votes of Black and Latino residents.

On Jan. 22, 2026, Manhattan state Supreme Court Justice Jeffrey Pearlman agreed. He wrote that the residents had shown "strong evidence of [a] racially polarized voting bloc," that they had "demonstrated a history of discrimination," and that racial appeals still show up in campaigns there, according to amNewYork's report. Roll Call reported that he found the map broke a clause in the state constitution. He barred the 2024 map from being used in any election and gave the state's redistricting commission until Feb. 6 to draw a new district.

The residents had proposed joining Staten Island with part of lower Manhattan, which leans heavily Democratic, and moving the Brooklyn part into the 10th District. Malliotakis called the case "meritless" and said she'd take it to the U.S. Supreme Court.

What the Supreme Court did

She did. On March 2, the Supreme Court stopped the redraw while New York's own appeals courts heard the case. The order was unsigned and gave no reasons. The three liberal justices dissented.

Justice Samuel Alito wrote separately. He said the state judge's order "blatantly discriminates on the basis of race." Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in dissent that the court had taken "the astonishing, unexplained step of staying a state trial court's order" before New York's highest court could weigh in. She noted the order was just 101 words long.

So the court never said the map was fair. It said the 2024 lines would stay for the 2026 election, and it didn't say why.

What it was worth on Tuesday

Nobody can say how a district that was never drawn would have voted. Here's what we do know. CNBC reported that if the judge's order had gone into effect, Democrats likely would have had a better chance of beating Malliotakis. On the map she got to keep, she beat DeCillis by more than 22,000 votes.

Malliotakis's share still fell 8 points from 2024, the second-biggest drop of any Republican we track in New York. She is also one of twelve members of Congress trying to erase Trump's January 6 impeachment.

The rest of the ugly

A few more results from election night:

  • "The Democrats in NY will do anything and everything to cheat." That's what Claudia Tenney posted at about 7 a.m. on Election Day, after scanners across Westchester County stopped reading ballots. Westchester isn't in her district. State officials blamed a software update made after the machines were tested. The ballots were bagged, to be scanned later with party representatives watching. Mike Lawler, whose own race was on those ballots, said "There's no shenanigans going on here." Tenney won by 20.
  • Elise Stefanik's old seat went to a man who called reporters "scumbags." Anthony Constantino, the Sticker Mule CEO, beat Democrat Blake Gendebien in the 21st District 50.8% to 49.0%, by 4,856 votes. Stefanik won the seat with 62% in 2024. In his 31-minute victory speech, Constantino told the press, "Listen to me, scumbags," called reporters "a bunch of f---ing a--holes," had one thrown out, and said Trump "should consider freeing Diddy," Fox News reported.

What the results show

Cait Conley beat Mike Lawler 53.0% to 46.9%, and Democrats won back a two-thirds supermajority in the state Senate, including a Long Island seat Republicans had held since 1914. Kathy Hochul won by nearly 20 points and carried both Long Island counties. The five Republicans we track who won all did worse than in 2024: Nick LaLota by about 2 points and Andrew Garbarino by about 3. Nicole Malliotakis won by 12 on a map a state judge had ordered redrawn. The U.S. Supreme Court kept those lines for this election, in a 101-word order that gave no reason.

Source

Where do all the key New York state legislative races stand? — Annie McDonough, City & State New York, November 4, 2026.

Take Action →