Dan Sullivan Election DenialVoting Rights Alaska

Dan Sullivan Told CNN He'd Accept the Election Results. Mary Peltola Now Leads by 11,000 Votes, and He Still Hasn't Conceded.

Two days before the election, Sen. Dan Sullivan told Jake Tapper he would accept the results, then told viewers, 'Don't let this election be stolen.' Peltola has since pulled ahead by more than 11,000 votes. Sullivan hasn't conceded, and he hasn't spoken out against the Trump lawsuit trying to block Alaska from certifying the race.

Dan Sullivan Told CNN He'd Accept the Election Results. Mary Peltola Now Leads by 11,000 Votes, and He Still Hasn't Conceded.
Photo: U.S. Senate official portrait, via Wikimedia Commons

Two days before Election Day, Jake Tapper asked Dan Sullivan a simple question on CNN's State of the Union.

"Are you only going to accept the election results if you win?"

"No, I'm going to accept the election results," Sullivan said, according to CNN's transcript.

Then, as Tapper thanked him, the senator got in one last line: "And to all the Alaskans watching, get out there and vote. Don't let this election be stolen."

Two weeks later, Alaska has counted most of its ballots and Democrat Mary Peltola is ahead. Alaska reporter Dermot Cole wrote on Saturday that she leads by more than 11,000 votes and that Sullivan "has yet to make good on his pre-election promise to accept the results, win or lose."

The count is not close anymore

On election week, the race was razor thin. Peltola led by just 637 votes with a quarter of the ballots still out.

That lead has grown with every update. By November 11, the Alaska Division of Elections count had Peltola at 121,487 first-choice votes, or 48.9%, to Sullivan's 117,512, or 47.3%. Cole's Saturday tally put her lead past 11,000.

Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, and the state runs that count on November 18. That count matters here because a second man named Dan Sullivan — Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. of Petersburg — was also on the ballot. The theory is that his voters were confused and really meant to pick the senator.

The early data says otherwise. Of the 4,055 voters who ranked the Petersburg Sullivan first, the Anchorage Daily News found, nearly 30% ranked Peltola second. About 16% ranked the senator second. Cole wrote that even if every vote for the other Dan Sullivan went to the incumbent, Peltola would still win.

A promise with an escape hatch built in

Look again at what Sullivan said on CNN. He promised to accept the results, then told Alaskans not to let the election "be stolen" — in the same breath.

That second line did a job. It planted the idea that if he lost, it would be because someone stole it. And he had already been telling voters exactly who he thought the thief was. In a CNN interview on Election Day, the Daily News reported, he called the second Sullivan's candidacy "the biggest cheating scandal in Alaskan history" and warned that "there could be thousands of Alaskans who throw away their vote." We've written about how his own party fought to keep an imprisoned felon on the ballot as a Democrat two years earlier, when a spoiler helped Republicans.

Cole points out that this is a turnaround, too. Back in July, he wrote, Sullivan said his campaign would make sure Alaska voters knew which Sullivan was which. After Trump took up his cause, the senator started claiming that thousands of voters would probably pick the wrong man.

He won't speak up about the lawsuit to stop the count

The biggest test of Sullivan's promise is a lawsuit filed on his behalf — though not by him.

Trump's Justice Department sued to stop Alaska from certifying its Senate election, but only if Sullivan lost. Federal Judge Sharon Gleason threw the case out. The administration has now asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to step in.

Two election experts have asked the appeals court to uphold the dismissal. In a proposed brief to the appeals court, UCLA election law professor Richard Hasen wrote that "the federal government asserts especially broad powers, seeking to block certification but providing no details as to how and when Alaska's certification process could be altered." A second brief from Stephen Richer, the former Maricopa County recorder now at the Cato Institute, says the "unprecedented nature of this case underscores its lack of merit." Alaska's own Department of Law says the suit has no merit.

A senator who planned to accept the results would say the federal government has no business blocking his state from certifying them. Sullivan hasn't. According to Cole, he has said he has no opinion he can share with Alaska voters. A campaign worker offered this instead: "We'll let the DOJ complaint run its course."

Cole reports that Sullivan, a former Alaska attorney general, has also called the situation "Watergate 2.0." On whether a crime took place, he said, "Look, I'll let the lawyers figure that out."

Meanwhile, Gov. Mike Dunleavy keeps floating the idea that Sullivan might challenge the results in court, Cole writes, without explaining what the grounds would be.

This is the playbook

None of this happened on its own. Trump demanded the other candidates' votes be handed to Sullivan and the election declared over. House Oversight Chairman James Comer said there was a "big possibility" Peltola wouldn't be seated even if Alaskans elected her. The Justice Department sued to block the result.

Every one of those moves was made on Sullivan's behalf. The one person who could shut them down by saying "I lost, and the count was fair" is Sullivan. He told a national TV audience he would. He hasn't.

In summary

On November 1, Dan Sullivan told CNN, "I'm going to accept the election results," then told viewers, "Don't let this election be stolen." Mary Peltola now leads him by more than 11,000 votes, and early data shows that voters who picked the second Dan Sullivan first were nearly twice as likely to rank Peltola second as to rank the senator second. Sullivan has not conceded, and he has not spoken against the Trump administration's lawsuit to stop Alaska from certifying the race, which a federal judge already dismissed.

Source

Sullivan claimed he would accept election results. Will he? — Dermot Cole, Reporting From Alaska

Take Action →
Dan Sullivan Report Card