John McGuireRob WittmanJen KiggansBen ClineMorgan Griffith Voting Rights Virginia

Virginia Election 2026: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

Democrats beat Rob Wittman and Jen Kiggans, and Virginians wrote abortion, marriage and voting rights into the state constitution with up to 62.8% of the vote. John McGuire held on by 5,748 votes on the old map, after four Republicans on this site went to court against the redistricting amendment voters approved in April and a 4–3 state Supreme Court threw it out.

Virginia Election 2026: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
Photo: Nathaniel Cline / Virginia Mercury

On Nov. 3, Democrats took control of the U.S. House and Senate. Virginia did its part. Two of the five Republicans on this site lost their seats, and the three who won did it by less than last time.

But the Republicans fought this election in court months before anyone voted in it. Back in April, Virginians approved an amendment to redraw the state's congressional map. Four Republicans on this site went to court to stop it, and the state's top court threw it out. So the election ran on the old lines, and one of the men who sued held on by fewer than 6,000 votes.

Here's the good, the bad and the ugly.

The good: two seats flipped, three rights written in

Virginia's 11 U.S. House seats went into the night split 6–5 for Democrats. They came out 8–3.

Jen Kiggans lost to Elaine Luria, the Navy veteran she beat in 2022. With 99% counted as of Nov. 15, Luria had 53.2% to Kiggans' 44.3%, a lead of 30,559 votes, according to NBC News. Two years ago Kiggans won this Virginia Beach seat with 50.8%. The Associated Press called it for Luria at 11:47 p.m. on election night. Kiggans posted that Luria made more than $21 million from insider trading. Luria reported two stock trades in four years, and Kiggans' campaign pointed to no case of insider trading.

Rob Wittman lost to Shannon Taylor, the top prosecutor in Henrico County. Taylor had 51.3% to Wittman's 48.4%, a lead of 11,846 votes, according to NBC. Wittman won the same district with 56.4% in 2024. Taylor ran on bringing back Medicaid money and the health insurance tax credits that expired, and on Wittman's vote for Trump's budget bill, the Mercury reported. Wittman ran an ad blaming her for babies hurt at a Henrico hospital, and two fact checks rated it false.

Then there were the three ballot questions. Each one asked voters to add a right to the state constitution, and each one passed:

  • Question 1, reproductive rights: 62.8% yes. It protects birth control, fertility treatment and abortion. Every Republican in the General Assembly opposed it on its way to the ballot. More people voted yes on it (2,244,364) than voted for Mark Warner (2,234,930) in his own landslide, a sign, the Mercury reported, that Republican and independent voters backed it too. Kiggans, Wittman and John McGuire had all voted for or cosponsored abortion bans and restrictions.
  • Question 2, marriage: 57.8% yes. It removes the 2006 ban on same-sex marriage from the constitution and says "two adults may marry regardless of sex, gender, or race."
  • Question 3, voting rights: 56.8% yes. People with felony convictions now get their vote back automatically when they finish their sentence, instead of having to ask the governor.

The shares are NBC's count with 99% in.

And at the top of the ticket, Democratic Sen. Mark Warner beat retired Army Maj. Gen. Bert Mizusawa 61.5% to 38.3%, a margin of 843,905 votes, according to NBC. Six years ago Warner won by 12 points. This time he won by 23.

The bad: they won, by less

Three Republicans on this site won. All three won by less than in 2024. The counts are NBC's, with 99% in as of Nov. 15.

John McGuire held the 5th District with 49.9% to Democrat Tom Perriello's 48.3%, a margin of 5,748 votes. Two years ago he won it with 57.5%, a 15-point win. The AP didn't call the race until two days after the election. When Perriello conceded, his campaign said he had moved all 24 counties in the district toward Democrats and helped flip the Lynchburg City Council. In his concession, Perriello said he will keep fighting "this generational assault on rural and maternal healthcare." McGuire calls Trump's budget bill "the biggest investment in rural hospitals in history." Meanwhile three hospitals in his own district are at risk of closing.

The others:

The ugly: the vote they went to court to undo

The closest race on this site in Virginia was McGuire's. It was run on the old map, because four Republicans on this site, McGuire among them, went to court against the amendment that would have replaced it.

What voters approved

Last fall, after President Trump pushed Texas and other Republican states to redraw their maps for more Republican seats, Virginia Democrats answered with a constitutional amendment of their own. It would let the legislature redraw the state's congressional districts before the next census. Democrats believed their proposed map could produce a 10–1 delegation, up from the 6–5 edge they had.

That was a partisan map, and Democrats didn't hide it. The map it would have replaced was drawn by the Supreme Court of Virginia in 2021, not by Republican lawmakers. But in Virginia, an amendment like this one isn't a deal politicians make among themselves. Voters have to approve it. On April 21, more than three million Virginians voted, and the amendment passed by about three points.

How they got it thrown out

Republicans went to court before the vote and after it.

In February, the Republican National Committee, the House Republicans' campaign committee, Ben Cline and Morgan Griffith asked a judge in Tazewell County, in Southwest Virginia, to stop the vote. Judge Jack Hurley granted an emergency order halting the April 21 election. He said the Republicans had an "extraordinarily high likelihood of success." House Speaker Don Scott, a Democrat, said Republicans had "ran back to the same judge" even though the law requires these cases to be filed in Richmond. The Supreme Court of Virginia let the vote go ahead.

The day before, John McGuire and Rob Wittman had filed their own suit in Richmond. It went after the ballot question's wording, which asked whether to amend the constitution "to restore fairness in the upcoming elections."

Here is what Cline said when the judge stopped the vote: "This ruling is an important victory in our fight to make sure that politicians don't get to select their own voters." The ruling he was celebrating stopped voters from voting.

Voters approved the amendment anyway. The day after, Hurley blocked the state from certifying the result, in the case Cline and Griffith had brought with the RNC. He had already ruled in January, in a separate suit brought by Republican state lawmakers, that the amendment was unconstitutional.

What the court actually ruled

On May 8, the Supreme Court of Virginia struck the amendment down, 4–3.

The court didn't rule on whether the map was fair. It ruled on timing. Virginia's constitution makes the legislature pass an amendment twice, with an election in between, so voters can weigh in when they pick their lawmakers. Democrats first passed this one on Oct. 31, 2025, when early voting in that fall's state House elections had already started. The majority said that denied more than 1.3 million Virginians a voice in the debate.

Attorney General Jay Jones, a Democrat, said the court's "Republican-appointed majority" had twisted the plain language of the constitution. President Trump called the ruling a "Huge win for the Republican Party."

What it was worth on Nov. 3

The 2021 map stayed. Under it, Republicans kept three of Virginia's 11 seats, instead of the one seat Democrats believed their map could leave them.

McGuire's 5th District is one of those three. He won it by 5,748 votes. Last year, Republican Winsome Earle-Sears carried the district for governor by 7.6 points while losing the state by 15. This year Perriello came within 1.6.

On election night, before the AP had called the race, McGuire declared victory. Perriello said it was too close to call. When the AP called it two days later, McGuire wrote, "By the grace of God we won." The man who won is the same one who went on Newsmax and said the COVID vaccine was a "BLT sandwich of fetus baby parts".

The rest of the ugly

  • The same judge gets the next amendment. On Nov. 24, Judge Hurley is set to hear a challenge to the reproductive rights amendment, the one that passed by 25 points. The suit was brought by the Family Foundation, a conservative group. It says the House clerk didn't send copies of the amendment to circuit court clerks around the state. A law Gov. Abigail Spanberger signed in March removed that requirement, and made the change apply to the past as well. Hurley, who retires Dec. 31, says he'll rule before he leaves.
  • The marriage amendment is in court too. The same group's legal arm has also sued on behalf of a Prince William County pastor to undo the marriage amendment. "This fight is not over. It moves today to the courtroom and the Capitol," the Family Foundation's president, Victoria Cobb, said on election night.

What the results show

Democrats beat Jen Kiggans by 30,559 votes and Rob Wittman by 11,846, turning Virginia's House delegation from 6–5 to 8–3. Voters added reproductive rights, marriage and automatic restoration of voting rights to the state constitution, with 56.8% to 62.8% voting yes. Ben Cline, Morgan Griffith and John McGuire all won by less than in 2024. McGuire's margin was 5,748 votes, on the old map. He, Wittman, Cline and Griffith had gone to court against the redistricting amendment voters approved in April, and a judge and a 4–3 state Supreme Court threw it out.

Source

Warner wins fourth term, Luria ousts Kiggans in VA-02, Taylor triumphs in VA-01 — Markus Schmidt, Virginia Mercury, November 3, 2026 (updated November 5).

Take Action →