Social Security

Sen. Ron Johnson Says Social Security Can't Be Fixed. 'You Just Shut It Down.'

On Fox Business, Wisconsin Republican Ron Johnson called Social Security 'a scam,' 'grotesque' and 'a Ponzi scheme,' and said 'you just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money.' He has pushed to end its guaranteed benefits before.

Sen. Ron Johnson Says Social Security Can't Be Fixed. 'You Just Shut It Down.'
Photo: MS NOW

On November 18, two weeks after the midterms, a Republican senator went on national TV and said the quiet part about Social Security out loud.

"It's a Ponzi scheme," Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson said on Fox Business. "You can't fix it; you just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money."

That's from MS NOW's Steve Benen, who reported both of Johnson's TV appearances that day. Johnson also called the program "a scam" and "grotesque."

A sitting U.S. senator is telling the people who count on Social Security that the answer is to end it.

What he said, twice in one day

Johnson's Fox Business interview wasn't a slip. He made the same case on Newsmax, ahead of a Senate Budget Committee hearing on Social Security's future.

"The SEC defines a Ponzi scheme as a fraudulent investment that pays early investors with the current investors," he said there. "That's exactly what Social Security does."

On Fox Business, he spelled out what he thinks is wrong with it: "Your benefits will be paid for by your children and grandchildren, and now money borrowed from the public."

He's describing how Social Security is designed to work: today's workers pay for today's benefits. A Ponzi scheme is a fraud that hides where the money comes from. Social Security is a program Congress wrote into law, in the open.

He's been working toward this for years

This isn't a new position for Johnson. It's the same one, said more plainly.

During his 2022 reelection race, Johnson said he wanted to move Social Security into the part of the federal budget that Congress has to approve every year. That would end the guarantee that benefits get paid automatically, and put them up for cuts every year in a budget fight. He also said the program "was set up improperly" and argued its money would have been better off in the stock market.

Democrats hammered him for it. He won by about one point.

He's now expected to run again in 2028, and MS NOW notes he has made himself the Senate's loudest opponent of the program ahead of that race.

What Americans actually think

Social Security is one of the most popular things the federal government does. A 2025 Bipartisan Policy Center poll found that 93% of Americans see Social Security as valuable, the highest rating of any federal program it asked about.

Benen notes that other Republican officials share Johnson's views but avoid saying so in public.

He's not the only one

Johnson is just the bluntest. Other Republicans have used the same line.

Alabama Sen. Tommy Tuberville stood on the Senate floor and called Social Security a government-approved Ponzi scheme, and collected about $93,000 from it himself in his first three years in office. Ron Estes, who chairs the House subcommittee in charge of Social Security, told Newsmax he was looking forward to what DOGE would find there. The agency then lost 6,645 employees between January and November 2025.

And when reporters asked Republican Senate candidates this fall how they'd stop the automatic 22% benefit cut coming in 2032, four didn't respond and three offered promises with no plan.

Johnson at least gave one. His plan is to stop paying.

The bottom line

On November 18, 2026, Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin called Social Security "a scam," "grotesque" and "a Ponzi scheme" on Fox Business, and said "you can't fix it; you just shut it down." He has pushed before to strip the program's guaranteed benefits and make them part of Congress's yearly budget fight. Ninety-three percent of Americans call Social Security a valuable program, and Johnson is expected to ask Wisconsin voters for another term in 2028.

Source

Take Action →