Ben Cline Social Security Virginia

Ben Cline Led the Republican Study Committee Budget That Would Have Raised the Social Security Retirement Age to 69. Now He's Running the Caucus Behind It.

Ben Cline has been elected chair of the Republican Study Committee, the largest bloc of House Republicans. In 2023 he led the task force that wrote its budget, which would have made future retirees wait until 69 for full Social Security benefits — a cut of about 13%.

Ben Cline Led the Republican Study Committee Budget That Would Have Raised the Social Security Retirement Age to 69. Now He's Running the Caucus Behind It.
Photo: Official portrait, U.S. House of Representatives, via Wikimedia Commons

Ben Cline has a new job. This week the Virginia congressman was elected chair of the Republican Study Committee, the biggest group of conservatives in the House. He'll lead it in the next Congress.

"I do not take this responsibility lightly," Cline said in a statement.

Here's what he isn't saying. The last time Cline was in charge of writing down what this group believes, he put a cut to Social Security in it.

He ran the team that wrote the budget

In January 2023, Cline was picked to chair the RSC's Budget and Spending Task Force. He told WHSV the job was to put out a balanced budget that "saves Medicare and Social security from bankruptcy."

That June, the budget came out. Roll Call reported that the plan from the 175-member group would gradually raise the age at which future retirees can claim full Social Security benefits — from 67 to 69.

Cline explained how it would work himself. According to Roll Call:

  • People who were 59 at the time would see their retirement age go up three months every year, starting in 2026.
  • It would keep climbing until it hit 69 for people who turn 62 in 2033.
  • It would not touch people already retired or close to it.

The plan never became law. But had it passed, the higher retirement age would have started kicking in this year, 2026.

Raising the retirement age is a benefit cut

Politicians like to say "raising the retirement age" because it sounds like a technical fix. It isn't. If you have to wait two more years for your full check — or take a smaller check if your body can't wait — you get less money for the same years of work.

The Center for American Progress looked at the RSC plan and found:

  • Once the age hits 69 in 2033, every new retiree after that would see benefits cut by about 13%.
  • The budget also called for two more benefit cuts for future retirees and harsh changes to Social Security disability.
  • All together, the Social Security changes would cut $718 billion over 10 years.

Think about who that hits. Not a member of Congress. It hits the person who has stocked warehouse shelves, driven a truck, or worked a farm for 40 years, and whose knees and back are done at 62.

It wasn't only Social Security

The same budget went after Medicare too. Roll Call reported it proposed a "premium support" plan that would subsidize private insurance plans competing with traditional Medicare — similar to budgets Paul Ryan pushed for years, which even Donald Trump had panned.

And while it asked future retirees to wait longer, it offered what its backers called a $5.1 trillion tax cut over 10 years. The biggest piece — $2.48 trillion — was making the 2017 Trump tax cuts permanent.

The White House at the time called the RSC budget "a devastating attack on Medicare, Social Security, and Americans' access to health coverage and prescription drugs."

Cline's answer, in Roll Call: "We are taking action, whereas the White House and Democrats refuse to acknowledge that Social Security and Medicare are facing insolvency."

There are other ways to take action. Roll Call noted the Democrats' approach: raise Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes on high earners. The plan Cline led did the opposite. It asked workers to wait longer while giving the wealthiest a bigger tax cut.

This is a pattern in the RSC, not a one-time idea

Cline isn't the only member of the group to float this. Wisconsin's Tom Tiffany said raising the retirement age "should be discussed" a month before the 2023 RSC budget came out. And the RSC's outgoing chair, August Pfluger, spent this year writing a second budget-bill blueprint designed so Democrats couldn't block it.

Now the man who ran the team behind the retirement-age plan gets the gavel. In the new Congress, Republicans are in the minority, so the RSC can't pass its budget on its own. But it is still where House Republicans write down what they'd do if they got power back. Cline is the one holding the pen.

Why it matters in the Shenandoah Valley

Cline represents Virginia's 6th District, which takes in the Shenandoah Valley. The Augusta Free Press's headline this week put it plainly: he now chairs a "House Republican group that wants to cut Social Security."

The bottom line

In 2023, Ben Cline chaired the Republican Study Committee task force whose budget would have raised the full Social Security retirement age from 67 to 69 for future retirees — a benefit cut of about 13%, part of $718 billion in Social Security cuts over 10 years — alongside a $5.1 trillion tax cut. This week the group elected him its chair.

Source

Take Action →
Ben Cline Report Card