Erin HouchinJefferson ShreveJim BairdMark MessmerMarlin StutzmanRudy YakymVictoria Spartz Healthcare Indiana

Trump's Own Medicaid Officials Offered Indiana Six More Months Before Cutting People Off. Indiana Said No — With 58,000 Hoosiers Not Meeting the Rules.

Indiana won't use the optional six-month grace period the Trump administration created for Medicaid work requirements, which start January 1. The state's own estimate is that 58,000 people on the Healthy Indiana Plan aren't meeting the rules. All seven Indiana House Republicans on our report cards voted for the law that created them.

Trump's Own Medicaid Officials Offered Indiana Six More Months Before Cutting People Off. Indiana Said No — With 58,000 Hoosiers Not Meeting the Rules.
Photo: Makenzie Huber/South Dakota Searchlight, via Indiana Capital Chronicle

Last week, the Trump administration gave states more time. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services offered states an optional six-month grace period — a window when they could stop denying or cutting people off over the new work rules while they fixed their systems. We covered that decision here.

On Thursday, Indiana turned it down.

The state's own estimate, according to the Indiana Capital Chronicle, is that 58,000 Hoosiers on the Healthy Indiana Plan aren't meeting the new rules — the estimate the agency put out in October. Starting January 1, they can lose their health care.

What the rules are

Trump's budget bill, passed by Congress in 2025, requires most working-age adults covered through Medicaid expansion to prove they work, volunteer or go to school at least 80 hours a month. In Indiana, that's adults ages 19 to 64 on the Healthy Indiana Plan. State law now requires it too.

There's a catch that makes January 1 even closer than it looks. Indiana will use a three-month look-back to decide who's eligible, so some people already have to be in compliance right now to keep their coverage next year.

Indiana's excuse

The state's Family and Social Services Administration decided it can't take part. A spokesperson said "Indiana law does not provide the agency with the authority to delay implementation of these requirements."

Lawyers at the Indiana Justice Project, a nonpartisan legal group, say that's wrong. Executive Director Adam Mueller said the grace period doesn't delay anything. It only protects states from penalties if they hold off on denials and cutoffs while their systems catch up. He pointed out that Indiana law already lets the state change the Healthy Indiana Plan when it needs to in order to follow federal law.

"It is not a delay in implementation, it is smart implementation," Mueller said.

And Indiana's system clearly isn't finished. A federal judge recently threw out the federal definition of who counts as "medically frail" — the people who are supposed to be exempt — so the state has to rework that too. Democratic state Rep. Gregory Porter noted the agency is still hiring eligibility staff.

"Washington, D.C., admitted the timeline was unrealistic, and they offered this grace period," Porter said. "But the Braun administration chose to rush ahead." He added: "If this implementation goes awry, politicians won't pay the price. It's the Hoosiers who lose their access to healthcare."

This is the second time in two weeks

Indiana already stood out. Earlier this month, Indiana, Missouri and Iowa became the only three states to turn down all four hardship exceptions the law allows — the ones that let a state pause the rules after a disaster, a jump in unemployment, a hospital stay or a long trip for medical care.

Now it's turned down the grace period too. Arkansas, under Sarah Sanders, is sticking with January 1 too.

Indiana is also the state that has dropped a larger share of its children from Medicaid than any other.

The Republicans who wrote it into law

None of this happens without the law Congress passed. On July 3, 2025, the House gave final approval to Trump's budget bill, and all seven Indiana Republicans we track voted yes:

Indiana's state agency is the one pulling the trigger on January 1. But these seven are the reason there's a trigger to pull. They voted for a law that ties Hoosiers' health coverage to paperwork, and their state just passed up the breathing room Trump's own administration offered.

In summary

On November 19, 2026, Indiana said it won't use the Trump administration's optional six-month grace period for Medicaid work requirements, even though the state estimates 58,000 Healthy Indiana Plan members aren't meeting the rules that start January 1. It's the second safety valve Indiana has declined this month. All seven Indiana House Republicans we track — Baird, Houchin, Messmer, Shreve, Spartz, Stutzman and Yakym — voted for the budget bill that created the requirements.

Source

Take Action →