Immigration

ICE Set an Arrest Record in July by Grabbing People at Airports and a Swimming Hole in a National Forest

51,000 arrests in July, up from 43,000 in June — the most of the Trump administration. To get there, agents targeted airline passengers, set up a checkpoint at a creek in a national forest, and stopped trucks in four states. Less than a third of people in ICE detention have a criminal conviction.

ICE Set an Arrest Record in July by Grabbing People at Airports and a Swimming Hole in a National Forest

Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrested about 51,000 people in July — more than in any other month of the Trump administration, and up from 43,000 in June. The Department of Homeland Security confirmed the numbers to Stateline. It did not release state-by-state figures.

Even that is short of the White House's stated target of 2,000 arrests per day, which would be about 60,000 a month.

The interesting question isn't the total. It's how they got there.

Where the new arrests are coming from

Airports. DHS said that in July, agents arrested an average of 20 to 40 people per day at airports, targeting passengers with expired visas. Among those detained last month: a Cameroonian researcher at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, a Fulbright scholar and an expert in disease outbreaks, and an instructor at the University of Maryland from Ethiopia — picked up as he returned from a conference where he had accepted a Teacher of the Year award.

Michael Clemens, an economics professor at Johns Hopkins, explained the logic bluntly. Immigration authorities, he said, "see airports as an easy bottleneck because everyone in there is ID'd, so it's lower cost to seize people there than in any other place except a prison."

DHS put it more directly in its statement to Stateline: "this administration is working diligently to ensure that aliens in our country illegally can no longer fly unless it is out of our country to self-deport."

An asylum seeker from Zambia — a registered nurse at a hospital in Portland, Maine — was arrested at Boston Logan and released last Thursday after her detention set off protests. "Nurses in Maine found out one of their own was locked up and sprung into action to get her out," said Puneet Maharaj, a local nurse union representative.

A creek in a national forest. On July 26, agents set up a checkpoint near Wilson Creek in North Carolina, a Forest Service site popular with Hispanic families. Thirteen people were arrested, according to the local sheriff's office.

Methodist clergy and relatives of those arrested protested, saying at least some of them had no criminal record and had entered the country legally — directly contradicting a social media post by North Carolina's Republican House Speaker Destin Hall, who called them "a gang of previously arrested illegal aliens."

The Sierra Club objected too: "Bringing immigration enforcement into public recreation areas undermines the sense of safety and belonging that these spaces provide and could discourage people from visiting national forests and other outdoor spaces altogether."

Truck stops in four states. At the end of July, federal agents and state highway patrol officers ran roadside checks on trucks in Illinois, Indiana, Iowa and Ohio, framed as a crackdown on "illegal, unvetted drivers and unsafe vehicles." DHS said it detained 51 drivers who were in the country illegally.

The "worst of the worst" claim keeps not surviving contact with the data

The agency's standing justification is that it is "delivering on President Trump's promise to the American people to arrest and deport pedophiles, murderers, rapists, and other criminals."

The numbers Stateline reviewed through early July say otherwise:

  • Less than a third of people currently in ICE detention have a criminal conviction.
  • 40% have never been accused of anything other than a non-criminal immigration violation.

Colleen Putzel-Kavanaugh, an analyst at the nonpartisan Migration Policy Institute, said the new arrests are catching people in a legal "gray area" — like someone whose visa expired while they were applying for another legal status. Those people are not the "worst of the worst."

"The focus is so much on the arrest numbers that the mission seems a little confused to the general public," she said. "Meeting some arbitrary arrest quota doesn't necessarily serve this larger purpose of deporting a larger number of people, so there's a disconnect about what the mission really is."

That is the whole problem in one sentence. The target is a number, so the enforcement goes wherever bodies are easiest to collect — an airport security line, a swimming hole, a weigh station — rather than wherever the dangerous people are.

Kate Angustia of the American Immigration Lawyers Association pushed back on the framing that airport detainees had forfeited their status by letting visas lapse. "Many of these folks are in a lawful period of authorized stay," she said. "This means that longstanding policy and practice has been, for decades, to allow these people to remain here as their legal processes continue to be processed by the government."

It's about to get worse in September

A new rule takes effect in September setting stricter time limits on visas for students, exchange visitors and foreign media. More people will fall out of status, which means more people will be arrestable at an airport counter.

Clemens estimated that by limiting how many international STEM students, instructors and researchers are in the country, the rule could cost the U.S. economy as much as $145 billion a year by 2035.

"Implementation of the rule will cause large numbers of highly-skilled students and scholars to fall out of status," he said. "We'll certainly be seeing a lot more cases like the seizure of Fatima Ameaka" — the Johns Hopkins researcher from Cameroon.

The courts are the only brake

About 2,000 detainees a month are being freed after court-ordered bond hearings, as federal judges — including some appointed by Trump — rule against the administration's policy of mandatory detention. The Supreme Court is expected to take up whether that policy is legal in its October term.

Meanwhile, July also brought two immigrants shot and killed during traffic stops, in Texas and Maine, and a Mexican man with a valid tourist visa struck and killed by a truck after fleeing ICE officers who pulled him over in St. Augustine, Florida.

After a brief pause, Trump ordered the traffic stops to continue, with the concession that ICE officers will now wear body cameras when they pull drivers over. That is the same body-camera policy Maine's senator voted against requiring in June and then took credit for in August.

Who signed off on this

None of this is free-floating. In the early morning of June 5, the Senate voted 52–47 to pour nearly $70 billion into ICE and Border Patrol with no oversight and no transparency requirements. The social media surveillance dragnet ICE now runs was paid for out of the same pot.

An arrest quota is a policy choice. So is where the agents go to fill it.

Source