EducationJobs

The Trump Administration Just Canceled the Raises Head Start Teachers Were Promised. Many Earn Less Than $50,000.

A 2024 rule would have brought Head Start preschool teachers' pay up to what public preschool teachers earn, and expanded their health insurance and paid leave. The Trump administration has repealed it. More than 20% of Head Start teachers left in 2022.

The Trump Administration Just Canceled the Raises Head Start Teachers Were Promised. Many Earn Less Than $50,000.
Photo: Alejandro Granadillo / AP, via Boston 25 News

The Trump administration has canceled the raises that Head Start teachers were on track to get.

On Friday, the Department of Health and Human Services said it was finalizing the repeal of a 2024 rule that required large Head Start programs to raise teachers' pay, step by step, until it matched what local public preschool teachers earn. The rule also expanded teachers' health insurance and paid leave. The repeal was published Monday and takes effect in January.

Head Start is the federal preschool program for the country's poorest kids — more than 700,000 of them a year, including children who are homeless, in foster care or have disabilities.

What Head Start teachers earn

Most Head Start teachers have a bachelor's degree. According to data programs reported this year, those with a bachelor's degree earn less than $50,000 a year on average. Those with a master's degree earn less than $60,000.

The average public school teacher earns about $75,000, according to the National Education Association.

That's a gap of more than $25,000 a year between the average Head Start teacher with a bachelor's degree and the average public school teacher. The 2024 rule was built to narrow it, by requiring pay to match what local public preschool teachers earn. Biden's plan would have raised pay by about $10,000 over the next five years.

Teachers are already leaving

That gap has a cost, and kids pay it. More than 20% of Head Start teachers left in 2022, the AP reported, some going to public schools and some to retail or food service jobs. Turnover was still 17% last year, according to HHS data cited by Common Dreams.

When teachers leave, classrooms close. The AP reported that some programs have been unable to hire enough staff to run at full size and have had to shut classrooms and even whole centers.

The administration's argument is that dropping the pay mandate saves money, which programs can use to enroll more children. "The Trump Administration is working hard to ensure that the promise of Head Start reaches as many children as possible with the funds Congress has appropriated," said Alex J. Adams, the HHS official who oversees Head Start.

The National Association for the Education of Young Children, the early-education professional association, pointed out the hole in that logic:

"A funded slot without a qualified teacher serves no one."

The group noted that the administration's own rule says its estimate of 106,000 extra slots doesn't predict how many children will actually be served — because that depends on whether programs can find teachers to staff the classrooms.

This is a workers' issue

Head Start teachers are workers, and this rule was a raise, better health insurance and more paid leave for them. Taking it away is a choice about whose work is worth paying for.

The rule would have cost about $2.1 billion a year by 2031, according to the AP. Common Dreams set that against the $1.5 trillion Pentagon budget the defense secretary has requested. Trump himself said months ago that the federal government "can't take care of daycare" because "we're fighting wars."

Sen. Patty Murray, a former preschool teacher, put it this way: "You can't help more kids with fewer teachers."

Part of a bigger push against Head Start

The pay rollback isn't a one-off. A White House budget draft last year proposed eliminating Head Start entirely. HHS has also proposed throwing out hundreds of the program's quality rules, including federal limits on how many children one teacher can be responsible for — deferring instead to state child care rules, which the AP notes tend to be looser.

Congressional Democrats wrote to the administration in June urging it to keep the pay requirements. It went ahead anyway.

The bottom line

The Trump administration repealed a rule that would have raised Head Start teachers' pay to match public preschool teachers and expanded their health insurance and paid leave. Head Start teachers with a bachelor's degree earn less than $50,000 a year on average, more than 20% of them left in 2022, and some programs have closed classrooms because they couldn't hire. The repeal takes effect in January.

Source

Trump administration cancels mandatory pay hike for Head Start teachers — The Associated Press, via Boston 25 News

Take Action →