Democrats said they want to give legal status to the roughly 436,000 young people who were brought to this country as children and protected by DACA. Randy Fine's answer was to call it "amnesty" for "foreign invaders."
On Tuesday, November 17, House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries — who is expected to become Speaker when Democrats take the House in January — said Democrats want to pass the American Dream and Promise Act, a bill that would give DACA recipients and people with temporary protected status (TPS) a path to permanent legal status. "We should actually move that bill immediately," Jeffries said, according to Florida's Voice.
Two days later, on November 19, Fine answered on X:
If you're listening, so-called Hakeem: I am a hard NO on giving any amnesty to foreign invaders.
Invaders can have DIGNITY at HOME.
They're NOT having it in America.
Who he's calling "invaders"
The bill Fine is answering would help two groups of people.
DACA recipients came to the U.S. as children. They didn't choose to come. To get DACA, they had to apply and meet rules on their criminal history and on schooling or military service. There were about 436,400 of them at the end of June 2026, according to USAFacts, drawing on government data. DACA protects them from deportation and lets them work, but it gives them no legal status and no path to citizenship. That's what the Dream and Promise Act would change.
TPS holders are people the U.S. government has given temporary protected status — permission to stay and work here for a time because of conditions in their home countries.
Neither group is an army. The government knows who they are, because they applied. Fine's word for the people this bill would help is "invaders."
He put DIGNITY in capital letters. That's also the name of the Dignity Act, the immigration bill of fellow Florida Republican Maria Elvira Salazar — a bill that, as we've reported, has never even had a hearing and doesn't lead to citizenship.
Why the word matters
"Invasion" is not a neutral way to describe immigration. It describes immigrants as an enemy army, and the people defending against them as soldiers.
That's exactly how it was used in El Paso. About 20 minutes before a gunman opened fire at a Walmart in August 2019, a screed was posted online saying the massacre was a response to an "invasion" of Hispanics coming across the southern border, the Associated Press reported. The writer called attacking "low-security" targets a way to "fight to reclaim my country from destruction." El Paso's police chief said investigators attributed the manifesto to the suspect.
Fine didn't call for violence. But he chose the same word, in answer to a bill for people who were brought here as kids.
This is a pattern
Fine reaches for language like this again and again:
- He has said "the barbarians" have won seats in Congress and told Americans to be afraid.
- When federal agents searched Rep. Ilhan Omar's home weeks before the election, Fine cheered that Trump was working to "reunite Omar with her countrymen in Somalia" — about a U.S. citizen and member of Congress.
Florida's Voice, a conservative outlet, notes that Fine has "drawn national attention for hard-line positions on immigration and for past remarks about Muslims and Palestinians." It also reports he has told Newsmax he would accept a government shutdown if Democrats tied government funding to amnesty or expanded benefits for immigrants here illegally.
He is also not alone in this kind of thinking. We found that an account that appears to be Andy Biggs's gave five stars to a book warning that Muslim immigrants will erase the West.
The bottom line
When Democrats said they'd move a bill giving legal status to about 436,000 DACA recipients — people brought to the U.S. as children — and to TPS holders, Randy Fine called it "amnesty" for "foreign invaders" and said they're "NOT having" dignity in America. "Invasion" is the same word the 2019 El Paso Walmart manifesto used to justify a massacre of Hispanic shoppers.
Source
Rep. Fine to Hakeem Jeffries: Hard no on amnesty for 'foreign invaders' — Florida's Voice
