Mike Rogers (MI) RacistLies Michigan

Mike Rogers Spent His Senate Race Tying a Muslim Opponent to Terrorism. Now a Dearborn Publisher Is Suing Him for Defamation.

Osama Siblani, editor of the Arab American News, sued Mike Rogers, his campaign, a 'Democrats for Mike Rogers' group and state Rep. Karen Whitsett, saying they falsely painted him as a defender of terrorists who told American Jews to go 'back to Poland' and bankrolled Abdul El-Sayed.

Mike Rogers Spent His Senate Race Tying a Muslim Opponent to Terrorism. Now a Dearborn Publisher Is Suing Him for Defamation.
Photo: Wikimedia Commons

The Michigan Senate race is over, and Mike Rogers (MI) lost it. But the campaign he ran is now headed to court.

This week, Osama Siblani, the editor of the Dearborn-based Arab American News, filed a defamation lawsuit in Wayne County Circuit Court. It names Rogers, his campaign, a group called Together for Michigan that ran as "Democrats for Mike Rogers," and outgoing state Rep. Karen Whitsett of Detroit, one of Rogers' chief surrogates among former Democrats.

The suit says they spread false statements of fact about Siblani. According to the complaint, the Rogers side falsely claimed that Siblani:

  • told American Jews to "return to Poland,"
  • justified the Hamas attacks on Israel on October 7, 2023,
  • defended terrorism more broadly, and
  • had a "group" that gave hundreds of thousands of dollars to Abdul El-Sayed, the Democrat Rogers was running against.

Siblani is asking for unspecified compensatory and exemplary damages and attorney fees, Deadline Detroit reported. "Siblani did not defend terrorists," the suit states.

What Rogers posted

The lawsuit points back to a Washington Free Beacon article that Rogers shared on social media, which called Siblani, among other things, "an unapologetic supporter of Hamas and Hezbollah." The Free Beacon isn't a defendant, and its editor told the Michigan Advance it stands by its reporting.

Then, on October 27, Rogers wrote on X:

"Siblani told Jewish Americans they should go back to Poland. Abdul said he was honored to have Siblani's endorsement. Abdul should disavow his endorsement and be held accountable for this hateful rhetoric that he champions."

Two days later, on October 29, a Together for Michigan ad named Siblani and called him a "notorious antisemite."

What Siblani actually said

The "Poland" line comes from a 2024 rally. Siblani's words, as quoted in the Michigan Advance, were: "And to Netanyahu who wants to bring their people to the north, we are going to take you back to Poland." He was answering Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's statement about bringing displaced Israelis home to northern Israel.

That is an ugly thing to say. "Go back to Poland" has been called antisemitic because it plays on the old smear that Jews have no ties to the land of Israel — CNN's Jake Tapper made that point about Siblani's remark in 2024.

But notice who the sentence is aimed at: Netanyahu, whose father was born in Poland. Siblani's lawsuit says exactly that — his statement "concerned only one individual," Netanyahu. Together for Michigan's lawyer argues that a "broad public audience" understood the "you" to mean "their people." But nothing in the quote is addressed to Jewish Americans — and that is who Rogers told voters it was aimed at. That gap — between what was said and what Rogers told voters was said — is the heart of the case.

Siblani's lawyer, James Allen, wrote that the claims were not "political opinions" but "purported statements of historical fact, attributed quotations, descriptions of specific conduct, and representations concerning objectively verifiable financial transactions." The money claim matters here: if Siblani's group really had funneled hundreds of thousands of dollars to El-Sayed, the suit says, that would break campaign finance law. The complaint calls every one of those allegations "demonstrably false."

How the other side responded

Rogers' campaign didn't answer either outlet's request for comment. Whitsett hung up on a Michigan Advance reporter twice.

The lawyer for Together for Michigan, Christine Fort, refused Siblani's November 2 demand for a retraction. She said the ad's statements "were not defamatory — they were true," and that Siblani, as a public figure, can't prove "actual malice." That is the bar the Supreme Court set: a public figure has to show the speaker knew a statement was false or recklessly ignored whether it was true.

Fort also wrote that the ad "made no affirmative representations regarding Mr. Siblani's sentiment toward Jewish Americans." That defense covers the ad. It doesn't cover Rogers' own post, which said Siblani "told Jewish Americans they should go back to Poland."

It fits a pattern

A court will decide whether this was defamation. What isn't in doubt is that this was how Rogers ran his race: by tying Muslims and Arab Americans in Michigan to terrorism, over and over, and by stretching what people actually said.

The Michigan Advance summed up the general election plainly: Rogers and his campaign were "heavily criticized" for using "Islamophobic rhetoric," and Rogers gave a platform to right-wing influencers who claimed El-Sayed and his family had ties to terrorist networks, including the Muslim Brotherhood.

The Siblani suit is the same move, aimed at a newspaper editor instead of the candidate: take a real quote, change who it was about, and tell voters it proves something it doesn't.

What the filings show

Osama Siblani is suing Mike Rogers (MI), his campaign, Together for Michigan and state Rep. Karen Whitsett for defamation. The suit says they falsely told voters he defended terrorists, bankrolled Abdul El-Sayed, and told American Jews to go "back to Poland." Rogers' October 27 post said Siblani told "Jewish Americans" to go back to Poland. The 2024 quote behind that claim was addressed to Benjamin Netanyahu. Rogers' campaign hadn't responded when the Michigan Advance and Deadline Detroit published.

Source

Michigan's Arab American News publisher sues Mike Rogers, campaign over alleged defamation — Michigan Advance, November 13, 2026

Take Action →
Mike Rogers (MI) Report Card