Mark Messmer Town Halls Indiana

Evansville Voted Against Mark Messmer. Less Than Two Weeks Later, He Closed His Evansville Office.

Indiana's 8th District congressman says his downtown Evansville office cost $40,000 a year and almost nobody came in. The constituents who rallied outside it, and delivered their questions to it, suggest otherwise. He has never held an in-person town hall there.

Evansville Voted Against Mark Messmer. Less Than Two Weeks Later, He Closed His Evansville Office.

Mark Messmer won a second term on November 3. He lost one county badly: Vanderburgh, home to Evansville, the biggest city in his district. His Democratic opponent, Mary Allen, took it with 57% of the vote, turning the county blue for the first time since 2008.

Less than two weeks later, Messmer told the Evansville Courier & Press he is shutting down his Evansville office.

His explanation

Messmer said the office, in the Fifth Third Center downtown, cost about $40,000 a year. He told the paper that in that time, about one person came by every other month to drop off paperwork.

"Maintaining a full-time office for that little foot traffic did not make sense," he said.

It's not the first one he's closed. At the start of 2025, he said, he also shut his Terre Haute office, which cost about $35,000 a year. That leaves exactly one full-time office in a district of 21 counties — in Jasper, his hometown.

Evansville will get a table instead. Staff will sit at the Vanderburgh County Commissioners Office in the Civic Center once a week. The first session the paper reported was one hour, 10 to 11 a.m. The old office was open 9 to 5, five days a week. And Messmer himself won't be at the table. The Courier & Press reported that only staff will be there.

The people who did show up

Messmer's "one person every other month" doesn't match what happened in front of that office.

In March 2025, Evansville residents held a "People's Town Hall" right outside it, protesting that their congressman wouldn't meet them. In July, Indivisible Evansville delivered handwritten questions and concerns from voters directly to the staff inside.

Those people weren't dropping off paperwork. They came to the office because it was the only place they could find their congressman's name on a door. Messmer has never come to them. In his whole first term, he did not hold a single in-person town hall anywhere in his 21 counties. His Republican predecessor, Larry Bucshon, did hold them in Evansville.

When about 70 people held a town hall for him this June anyway, he didn't come and never answered the invitation. And in March 2025, when about a dozen constituents — mostly seniors — came to one of his staff's mobile office hours at a library, the library's director said a Washington staffer asked her staff to call the police on them. The library refused. We laid out that whole record in our post on the empty chair.

So when Messmer says nobody uses his Evansville office, it's worth asking how welcome anyone was made to feel there.

$40,000 is too much for Evansville. A TV ad wasn't.

Messmer's case is about saving money. But this summer, he spent public money on something else: a 30-second TV spot about his border votes and Trump's budget bill. The FCC paperwork for the ad buy was labeled "IN-08 Franking" — taxpayer-funded congressional mail and ads — and the spot carried the disclaimer "Paid for by official funds authorized by the House of Representatives." It was scheduled to run 84 times, ending exactly 62 days before Election Day. We covered it in our post on the trumpet ad.

The price of that ad was blacked out in the FCC records, so we can't put a number beside the $40,000. But the choice is plain: when public money could help Messmer get re-elected, he spent it. When it pays for a door his constituents can walk through, he says it costs too much.

What it means for Evansville

Messmer says about 10 people a week call the office and get their forms emailed back and forth. That is the casework a congressional office exists for — Social Security checks, veterans' benefits, passports, Medicare problems. Plenty of people who need that help are older, don't use email, or need to sit down with someone to sort it out.

For them, the options now are a weekly staffed session at the Civic Center, or a drive to Jasper. The Jasper office is the only one left where they can walk in without an appointment.

The bottom line

Mark Messmer has never held an in-person town hall in Indiana's 8th District. Less than two weeks after Evansville voted against him, he announced he was closing his full-time office there. The office was open 40 hours a week; Evansville now gets weekly staff office hours — the first of them one hour long — without him. He says the $40,000-a-year office wasn't worth it. This summer, he used taxpayer money for a TV ad touting his votes.

Source

Rep. Mark Messmer closing down full-time Evansville office — Evansville Courier & Press

Take Action →
Mark Messmer Report Card