Voting Rights

The Trump Administration Wants Tax Records to Decide Who Counts in the Census. 38 Million People Don't File Taxes.

A proposed Census Bureau rule would count people where their tax records say they live. A new report using the bureau's own data says that could leave out as many as 38 million people who don't file — and risks undercounting about 1 in 5 Americans, citizens included.

The Trump Administration Wants Tax Records to Decide Who Counts in the Census. 38 Million People Don't File Taxes.
Photo: Sarah L. Voisin/The Washington Post via Getty Images, via Talking Points Memo

The Trump administration's plan to rewrite the 2030 census was sold as a way to stop counting immigrants. A new report says it could also stop counting tens of millions of people, citizens included — because they earn too little to file taxes.

In September, the Commerce Department, which runs the Census Bureau, proposed a rule changing how the census decides where you live. For generations, the answer has been simple: where you live and sleep most of the time. The new rule would make it the place "consistent with, and evidenced by, their tax records."

If your tax records don't put you somewhere, the census may not count you there — or at all.

Who doesn't have tax records

Lots of Americans aren't required to file federal taxes. If your household earns below a certain amount, you don't have to. That can include low-income workers, some gig workers and some self-employed small business owners.

The Coalition on Human Needs — a group of public interest organizations that includes the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, United Way and AFSCME — went through the Census Bureau's own research. It found that 11.5% of the population doesn't have any IRS forms at all. That's about 38 million people.

The bureau's research also found that as many as 30 million people had addresses in IRS records that didn't match their addresses in the 2020 census. Put the two together, and the coalition calculated that the rule risks undercounting around 20% of the entire population — whatever their immigration status.

"Overall, this proposal is so broken, you can't even tell which 20% of the country is going to be left out," the coalition's executive director, Christopher Kang, told TPM.

Tax forms were never meant for this

Tax returns aren't even required to list where a person lives. They exist so the IRS can reach the filer, not to say where that person sleeps at night.

The administration's own Treasury Department warned about this before the rule came out. Treasury officials suggested Commerce use tax information only as backup evidence of where someone lives, and advised that "no particular tax record is controlling." TPM reported that Commerce ignored them.

The rule doesn't even say clearly which tax forms count. It lists only "e.g., tax returns, W-2 forms," leaving it unclear whether people who get Medicaid, children's health coverage or some Supplemental Security Income benefits — who may have filed other forms — would be counted.

Why Republicans want a smaller count

The census decides how many seats each state gets in the House, and with them how many electoral votes. The Constitution says that count must reflect "the whole number of persons in each State."

TPM notes that Republicans have long tried to shift political power from blue states to red states by leaving immigrants out of that count. Alabama sued to do it before the 2020 census; the case was dismissed in 2021. TPM describes this rule as part of the administration's broader effort to increase Republican power. We covered its first pieces in September — leaving out undocumented immigrants, refugees and asylees, and ending questions about race.

What the new report shows is who else gets swept up: the people least likely to file taxes. That means the lowest-income Americans, in every state.

People already said no

Nearly 150,000 comments were submitted on the proposed rule, according to a coalition of data experts called Hands Off Our Census. 88% opposed it. The Census Bureau didn't respond to TPM's request for comment on the new report.

What the record shows

The Trump administration's Commerce Department proposed making tax records the test for where people are counted in the 2030 census, over the objections of its own Treasury Department. Using the Census Bureau's own data, a new report finds 38 million people have no IRS forms at all and as many as 30 million more have mismatched addresses, putting about 1 in 5 Americans at risk of being undercounted, citizens included. 88% of the nearly 150,000 public comments opposed the rule.

Source

Exclusive: 38 Million Low-Income People Could Be Excluded From Census Under New Trump Admin Rule, Report Finds — Talking Points Memo

Take Action →