Max Miller Controversy Ohio

Max Miller Told Voters Every Abuse Allegation Was 'Proven False.' A Judge Just Found One of Them 'Substantially True.'

An Ohio judge threw out Rep. Max Miller's defamation lawsuit against his ex-wife, found that her account of him dousing her with boiling water was 'substantially true' based on a recording of the two of them, and ordered him to pay about $76,000 of her legal costs.

Max Miller Told Voters Every Abuse Allegation Was 'Proven False.' A Judge Just Found One of Them 'Substantially True.'
Photo: Tom Williams / Getty Images, via The Hill

Max Miller sued his ex-wife for defamation in May. He said she was behind news stories accusing him of abusing her. On Monday, November 16, a judge threw the case out — and in doing so, found that one of the worst things she accused him of was true.

According to The Hill, Cuyahoga County Judge Joy Kennedy ruled that the allegation that Miller doused Emily Moreno with boiling hot water during a June 2024 argument was "substantially true." The judge pointed to an audio recording of the two of them discussing what happened.

"Plaintiff has not shown that the statement about dousing Defendant Moreno with boiling hot water are false," Kennedy wrote in a 15-page order.

Miller also has to pay for it. The judge ordered him to cover roughly $76,000 of his ex-wife's attorneys' fees and costs.

Three weeks ago, he told voters the opposite

A week before the election, Miller ran a TV ad telling Ohio voters the matter was closed. "Despite relentless press and investigations," he said in it, "every allegation against me was proven false."

That wasn't true when he said it. We laid out cleveland.com's fact-check of that ad on October 27: the paper found that no investigation and no court had proven any of the allegations false, and that the fact-check Miller cited as proof had said no such thing.

Now a court has looked at one of those allegations and gone the other way. Not "unproven." Not "could not be determined." Substantially true — on the strength of a recording in which, as Moreno's lawyer put it, Miller "admitted on a recording to his conduct."

The lawsuit he filed to make it go away

Miller is the one who brought this case. He sued Moreno, the daughter of Ohio Republican Sen. Bernie Moreno, claiming she had worked with a Cleveland law firm to feed abuse allegations to national media outlets. He said she did it to hurt his reelection campaign and to gain an edge in their custody fight. The couple filed for divorce in August 2024 and share one daughter.

His complaint zeroed in on a Daily Mail article that described the hot-water incident — an incident Miller tells differently.

The judge found he had nothing to back any of it up. According to The Hill, Kennedy ruled that Miller had produced no credible evidence that Moreno was one of the article's anonymous sources, or that she "caused the article to be published."

"For the foregoing reasons, construing the evidence in the light most favorable to Plaintiff, the Court finds that there is no credible evidence in support of Plaintiffs claims against Defendant Moreno," she concluded.

Kennedy also found Miller hadn't shown that his ex-wife acted with "actual malice." That is the standard a public figure, like a member of Congress, has to meet to win a defamation case.

Ohio has a law for exactly this kind of lawsuit

Moreno asked the court to dismiss the case under Ohio's anti-SLAPP law. "SLAPP" stands for Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation — a lawsuit meant to scare someone into silence. The law exists to stop people from using the courts to intimidate others out of speaking.

Her lawyer, Subodh Chandra, said that's what this was.

"Congressman Miller tried to use the courts as a weapon to intimidate his ex-wife and silence speech on a matter of vital public concern — allegations about an elected official's abusive behavior," Chandra said in a statement reported by The Hill.

It fits a pattern. Miller has answered people who talk about the allegations against him with threats. We documented the cease-and-desist letters, warning emails and texts Mother Jones found he'd sent to critics, and his letter threatening to sue TV stations for airing a county sheriff's ad about the allegations. The stations aired it anyway.

An attorney for Miller did not immediately return The Hill's request for comment.

The other allegations haven't gone away either

The hot-water incident is one of several accusations against him. Reports that surfaced in July said Miller held a gun to Moreno's head and broke their daughter's collarbone during the marriage. He denies all of it.

In July we covered 2,000 pages of records behind those allegations, including a child abuse investigation into the girl's broken collarbone. That investigation was ruled unsubstantiated. The House Ethics Committee opened its own investigation in August into allegations of domestic violence and illegal drug use.

Republican senators called on Miller to step aside. Instead he loaned his campaign $1 million and stayed on the ballot. On November 3 he lost to Democrat Brian Poindexter by more than 9 percentage points. He stays in Congress until January.

What the ruling shows

Max Miller sued his ex-wife for defamation and lost. A judge found her account of him dousing her with boiling hot water "substantially true," based on a recording of the two of them, found "no credible evidence" for his claims against her, and ordered him to pay about $76,000 of her legal costs. Three weeks earlier, he had told Ohio voters that every allegation against him had been "proven false."

Source

Take Action →
Max Miller Report Card